Articles in Category: Business

General business information that may be of interest to leaders and business owners

Real Estate Agents – It’s all about form – Is your commission at risk?

Victorian case


In the recent Victorian Supreme Court of Appeal decision of Advisory Services Pty Ltd (t/a Ray White St Albans) v Augustin & Anor [2018] VSCA 95 the Court found that an estate agent was not entitled to claim commission totalling $385,000 as their written authority did not contain the precise wording as required by the Estate Agents Act 1980 (Vic) (Act).


Augustin (Respondent) owned the property at 382 Greens Road, Keysborough and in signing an exclusive sale authority, engaged Advisory Services Pty Ltd (trading as Ray White St Albans) (Applicant) for the sale of the property. The Respondent sold the property however the purchaser defaulted under the Contract. The Respondent then engaged another agency to assist in selling the property once more, which the Applicant claimed was during the period of the exclusive sale authority. A dispute arose and the Applicant sued the Respondent for commission on both sales, totalling $385,000.

The trial judge in the Victorian County Court found that the authority was not enforceable, and therefore the Applicant was not entitled to that commission. The Applicant appealed that decision. The Victorian Supreme Court of Appeal looked at whether the Applicant was entitled to sue for any commission as their authority did not strictly comply with the Act.


The appeal was dismissed. The Victorian Supreme Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the trial judge and found that the Applicant was not entitled to the commission as its sale authority was unenforceable.

Pursuant to section 49A(4)(c) of the Act, an authority must contain a ‘rebate statement’, which statement:

  • is in a form approved by Consumer Affairs; and
  • states that an agent is not entitled to retain any rebate and must not charge the client an amount for any expenses more than their actual cost.

The Court found that the Act must be interpreted strictly in favour of consumers. A statement that an agent will not retain any rebate was held to be materially different to a statement that an agent is not entitled to retain any rebate. This is irrespective of whether the agent was seeking to retain a rebate in any event. Strict compliance is required.

The authority that was used by the agent in this instance contained language based on one of two forms approved by the Director of Consumer Affairs Victoria which is available for download from their website. One of these forms contains the satisfactory wording as required by section 49(4)(c) of the Act, but the other does not.

Impact of decision

Estate agents need to review their engagements and authorities to ensure they strictly comply with section 49(A) of the Act and contain the correct statements in accordance with the Act concerning the receipt of commissions.

As a result of the decision in this matter, the instructions for using the non-compliant form on the Consumer Affairs website have now been amended to note that agents still “need to include all the other requirements of section 49A” of the Act. Accordingly, agents cannot merely rely upon the forms posted on the Consumer Affairs website. This is the case notwithstanding that the statement itself, approved by the Director, provides that it is approved for the purposes of section 49A(4) of the Act.

The current form as approved by the Director of Consumer Affairs Victoria for circumstances where a rebate is not to be received does not contain wording sufficient to comply with the Act.

If you are an estate agent, it is imperative you ensure that your written engagement or appointment strictly complies with the Act. Non-compliance may result in:

  • over $15,000 in penalties for each breach of the Act;
  • you being unable to claim payments (including commission); and/or
  • you being sued for unlawfully claiming payments.

If you are a landowner who has sold a property or if you are in the process of selling a property and you have made or expect to make payments to an agent, you may wish to have your written engagement reviewed to determine your liabilities and whether the engagement strictly complies with the Act.

The REIV has taken steps to update its online forms and has provided advice to agents as to how to correct already purchased hard copies of sale authorities.

Ultimately, it is now incumbent upon the Victorian Parliament to immediately provide a legislative solution to rectify an obvious administrative error in the Consumer Affairs forms. While a legislative solution has been mooted, it is yet to be put before Parliament. We will be making submissions to the government in this regard.

Given the forthcoming election in November 2018, it will be interesting to see whether the government will prioritise the rectification of this important issue in the real estate industry.

Logie-Smith Lanyon Lawyers - Bryce Anderson and Jeremy Ashley

sourced from May 15 2018


Property Management Excellence (PME) private in agency training services

Property management risk management, compliance, time management and best practice

All education and training sessions are written and presented by Stacey Holt.

Queensland property management private training and consultancy services. 

"Property Management private training" services often also include consultancy and advice. As the training is interactive, with questions about systems and procedures asked and explored, the usual outcomes of most training in your office is revised systems and procedures for compliance, time management, risk management and best practice.  Contact us for a no obligation proposal  and to receive the 'private in agency training menu'. 

Click here to review the membership options for Queensland agencies. 

National real estate agency enters into enforceable undertaking

Sourced article

Not good news regrettably; however, your licensee, administrators, sales team and all your office might benefit from the following information as a reminder regarding the importance of compliance as nobody wants to be in this position. Stacey Holt.

5th March 2018

A national real estate agency has entered into two enforceable undertakings with the Office of Fair Trading (OFT), for alleged breaches of the Australian Consumer Law and the Property Occupations Act 2014.

Between November 2016 and June 2017, Purplebricks Australia Pty Ltd, entered into agreements with consumers who were not made aware of the terms of the fees charged. Consumers were also misled about additional services offered by Purplebricks, despite the agency advertising ‘low, fixed fees’ for their services when selling property.

Also during this period, Purplebricks failed to fulfil some of its regulatory obligations about use of appropriate accounts software, use of a non-Queensland bank account and notification of substitute licensees and other places of business.

The OFT received several complaints from consumers alleging false and misleading representations on the Purplebricks website and advertising regarding their fees, particularly that the fixed fees were payable regardless of whether a property was sold, or their services were cancelled.

The enforceable undertakings, which will remain in force for three years, require Purplebricks to pay a penalty of $20,000 and ensure that all representations made by the business, particularly those concerning fees and additional services, are not false or misleading.

The OFT acknowledged prior to entering into the enforceable undertaking, Purplebricks had amended their appointment forms and processes to ensure consumers were aware of the terms of their fixed fee charges, and amended their website and advertising to ensure consumers were not further misled.

Fair Trading Acting Executive Director Craig Routledge said the enforceable undertaking showed the business and its directors were willing to work with the OFT to ensure obligations were met.

“Queenslanders have the right to expect that real estate agents will make accurate and honest agreements with their clients,” Mr Routledge said.

“If real estate agents breach laws and industry regulations, the OFT will not hesitate to investigate and pursue if required.”

The OFT conducts a series of proactive compliance operations each year, targeting malpractice in the real estate industry. Real estate agents and consumers may report suspected misconduct directly to the OFT.

Associations and consumers may report misleading representations to the OFT by lodging a complaint at or by calling 13 QGOV (13 74 68).

An enforceable undertaking by the OFT is an alternative to court action where a breach of legislation is alleged. It is considered a legally binding agreement, which if broken can result in court action being commenced for breaking a term or condition of the undertaking, as well as seeking orders from the court to enforce the original undertaking.

Media enquiries

You can contact our media team directly  if you:

  • are a journalist or media representative
  • work for a newspaper (print or online), magazine, radio or television outlet
  • are producing a commissioned article.

The media team does not take enquiries from the general public.

Members of the public can contact us here ( ).

Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) ( )
Last updated
5 March 2018
Sourced from www. 6th March 2018

Property management training in your agency / group training

Queensland 'training menu" - please contact us for services outside of Queensland

The following sessions and topics below can be delivered to you and your team, at a time, date and venue that suit you. They can also be delivered in a variety such as one hour, two hours or three hours. The choice is yours. If your training and education needs are not listed in the “menu”, please let us know and we will do all we can to accommodate your needs. All education and training sessions focus on risk management, time management, compliance and best practice. Stacey Holt delivers all training services for Real Estate Excellence.

Download the Property Management Excellence training "Menu" here